In this haunting and deeply thought-provoking class, Rabbi Shafier explores the tragic story of Elisha ben Avuya, a towering sage who, after a profound spiritual experience, fell into heresy. Drawing from the Gemara’s account of the four who entered Pardes, Rabbi Shafier shows how only Rabbi Akiva emerged whole, while others were broken in devastating ways. Elisha’s downfall, rooted in a fatal misunderstanding of a heavenly message, becomes a powerful lesson about how spiritual confusion can lead a person astray. The class also confronts the difference between superficial regret and genuine teshuvah, emphasizing that true repentance must come from the deepest sincerity. Sobering, intense, and filled with timeless insight, this session leaves the listener reflecting on the stakes of spiritual integrity and the enduring hope for redemption.